gendesign/tradein-mvp/backend/app/services/matching/conflict_resolution.py
bot-backend f30f6acbf7
All checks were successful
CI / changes (pull_request) Successful in 8s
CI / backend-tests (pull_request) Has been skipped
CI / frontend-tests (pull_request) Has been skipped
CI / openapi-codegen-check (pull_request) Has been skipped
fix(matching): conflict_resolution picks freshest (last_seen_at) value, deterministic (#1539)
2026-06-17 22:43:59 +03:00

268 lines
11 KiB
Python

"""Per-field source priority for cross-source canonical merge.
Direct port of Cross_Source_Matching_Strategy.md sec 3.5 (houses) + 4.5 (listings).
Source-of-truth dicts read by merge logic in match_or_create_house/listing.
Sources covered: avito (serp/detail/houses_catalog/domoteka/imv),
cian (serp/bti/detail/stats/valuation), yandex (serp/detail/realty_nb/valuation).
"""
from __future__ import annotations
import logging
from typing import Any
logger = logging.getLogger(__name__)
# cross_validate: warn if spread between sources exceeds this fraction of the median.
_CROSS_VALIDATE_DIVERGENCE_THRESHOLD = 0.10
# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
# HOUSE_FIELD_PRIORITY — vault sec 3.5
# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
HOUSE_FIELD_PRIORITY: dict[str, list[str] | str] = {
"address": ["cian", "avito", "yandex"],
"lat": ["cian_serp", "avito_houses_catalog", "yandex_realty_nb"],
"lon": ["cian_serp", "avito_houses_catalog", "yandex_realty_nb"],
"year_built": [
"cian_bti",
"cian_serp",
"avito_houses_catalog",
"yandex_valuation",
"yandex_realty_nb",
],
"house_type": ["cian_bti", "cian_serp", "avito", "yandex_valuation", "yandex_realty_nb"],
"series_name": ["cian_bti"],
"passenger_lifts_count": ["cian", "avito"],
"cargo_lifts_count": ["cian", "avito"],
"has_concierge": ["cian", "avito"],
"closed_yard": ["cian", "avito"],
"parking_type": ["cian"],
"flat_count": ["cian_bti"],
"entrances": ["cian_bti"],
"is_emergency": ["cian_bti"],
"management_company_id": ["cian_valuation"],
"house_class": ["avito_houses_catalog", "cian", "yandex_realty_nb"],
"rating_score": ["avito_houses_catalog", "cian", "yandex_realty_nb"],
"reviews_count": ["avito_houses_catalog", "cian", "yandex_realty_nb"],
# Yandex unique fields (newbuilding landing only)
"text_reviews_count": ["yandex_realty_nb"], # 353 text reviews — Yandex strongpoint
"corpus_count": ["yandex_realty_nb"], # "три башни" → 3
"total_area_ha": ["yandex_realty_nb"], # ЖК footprint
"commission_year": ["cian_serp", "yandex_realty_nb"],
"commission_month": ["yandex_realty_nb"], # raw RU month name
"developer_name": ["cian", "yandex_realty_nb"],
"has_panorama": ["yandex_valuation"], # Yandex 3D panorama flag
"yandex_total_listings": ["yandex_valuation"], # "N объектов" в истории
# Yandex Valuation enrichment (existing house attrs)
"has_lift": ["cian_bti", "cian_detail", "yandex_valuation"],
"ceiling_height": ["cian_detail", "yandex_valuation"],
}
# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
# LISTING_FIELD_PRIORITY — vault sec 4.5
# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
LISTING_FIELD_PRIORITY: dict[str, list[str] | str] = {
"address": ["cian_serp", "avito_detail", "avito_serp"],
"lat": ["cian_serp", "avito_detail"],
"lon": ["cian_serp", "avito_detail"],
"area_m2": ["cian_serp", "avito_detail"],
"living_area_m2": ["cian_serp"],
"kitchen_area_m2": ["cian_serp", "avito_detail"],
"ceiling_height": ["cian_detail"],
"floor": ["cian_serp", "avito_detail"],
"total_floors": ["cian_serp", "avito_detail"],
"year_built": ["cian_serp"],
"house_type": ["cian_serp", "avito_detail", "yandex_detail"],
"repair_state": ["cian_detail", "avito_detail"],
"has_balcony": ["cian_serp", "avito_detail"],
"balconies_count": ["cian_serp"],
"loggias_count": ["cian_serp"],
"windows_view_type": ["cian_detail", "avito_detail"],
"separate_wcs_count": ["cian_detail"],
"combined_wcs_count": ["cian_detail"],
"room_type": ["cian_detail", "avito_detail"],
"has_furniture": ["cian_serp", "avito_detail"],
"phones": ["cian_serp"],
"description": ["cian_serp", "avito_detail", "yandex_detail"],
"photo_urls": "union",
# Avito Domoteka unique
"owners_count": ["avito_domoteka"],
"owners_at_least": ["avito_domoteka"],
"last_owner_change_date": ["avito_domoteka"],
"encumbrances_clean": ["avito_domoteka"],
"registry_match": ["avito_domoteka"],
# Cian-only
"is_rosreestr_checked": ["cian_serp"],
"is_layout_approved": ["cian_serp"],
"is_commercial_ownership_verified": ["cian_serp"],
# Cross-validation
"price_rub": "cross_validate",
"kadastr_num": "first_non_null",
# NOTE: task description claims price_rub=['cian','avito','yandex']; vault sec 4.5
# says 'cross_validate' (flag if diff > 10%). Following vault — change to list if
# cross_validate semantics aren't desired at caller.
# Yandex unique (agency block — OfferCardAuthorInfo)
"agency_name": ["yandex_detail"],
"agency_founded_year": ["yandex_detail"],
"agency_objects_count": ["yandex_detail"],
# Yandex parallel views column (NOT existing `views_total` which is Cian's)
"views_total_yandex": ["yandex_detail"],
# Yandex raw publish-date text (relative form)
"publish_date_relative": ["yandex_detail"],
}
def _freshest_non_null(
candidates: dict[str, Any],
timestamps: dict[str, Any] | None,
) -> Any:
"""Pick the non-null candidate from the freshest source (max last_seen_at).
Deterministic replacement for dict-insertion-order ``first_non_null`` (#1539).
Among sources with a non-null value:
* if ``timestamps`` is provided, choose the value whose source has the most
recent ``last_seen_at``; ties (equal / missing timestamps) break by source
name (lexicographic) so the result is reproducible regardless of dict order;
* if no usable timestamps are available, fall back to first non-null in
sorted-key order (still deterministic, unlike raw insertion order).
"""
non_null = {src: v for src, v in candidates.items() if v is not None}
if not non_null:
return None
timestamps = timestamps or {}
timed = [src for src in non_null if timestamps.get(src) is not None]
if timed:
# Freshest last_seen_at wins; equal timestamps tie-break by source name
# (lexicographically smallest) so the result never depends on dict order.
latest = max(timestamps[src] for src in timed)
winner = min(src for src in timed if timestamps[src] == latest)
return non_null[winner]
# No timestamps anywhere: deterministic by sorted source name.
return non_null[min(non_null)]
def _resolve(
priority: dict[str, list[str] | str],
field: str,
candidates: dict[str, Any],
timestamps: dict[str, Any] | None = None,
) -> Any:
"""Pick value from candidates per priority dict semantics.
``candidates`` maps source name -> value for ``field``. ``timestamps`` maps
source name -> ``last_seen_at`` (any comparable, usually ``datetime``); when
supplied it makes conflict resolution prefer the freshest source instead of
relying on non-deterministic dict insertion order (#1539).
"""
if not candidates:
return None
rule = priority.get(field, "first_non_null")
if isinstance(rule, str):
if rule == "union":
out: list[Any] = []
for v in candidates.values():
if v is None:
continue
if isinstance(v, list | tuple | set):
out.extend(v)
else:
out.append(v)
# Preserve order, dedup
seen: set[Any] = set()
uniq: list[Any] = []
for x in out:
key = repr(x)
if key in seen:
continue
seen.add(key)
uniq.append(x)
return uniq
if rule == "first_non_null":
return _freshest_non_null(candidates, timestamps)
if rule == "max":
non_null = [v for v in candidates.values() if v is not None]
return max(non_null) if non_null else None
if rule == "min":
non_null = [v for v in candidates.values() if v is not None]
return min(non_null) if non_null else None
if rule == "cross_validate":
# Return the median; flag divergence (vault sec 4.5: warn if diff > 10%).
nums = [v for v in candidates.values() if isinstance(v, int | float)]
if not nums:
return None
nums.sort()
n = len(nums)
if n % 2:
median = nums[n // 2]
else:
# True median for even n: mean of the two central values.
median = (nums[n // 2 - 1] + nums[n // 2]) / 2
if median and (max(nums) - min(nums)) > _CROSS_VALIDATE_DIVERGENCE_THRESHOLD * abs(
median
):
logger.warning(
"cross_validate divergence for field %r: min=%s max=%s median=%s "
"(spread exceeds %.0f%% of median); candidates=%r",
field,
min(nums),
max(nums),
median,
_CROSS_VALIDATE_DIVERGENCE_THRESHOLD * 100,
candidates,
)
return median
# Unknown rule — same deterministic freshness fallback as first_non_null.
return _freshest_non_null(candidates, timestamps)
# Priority list: pick value from highest-ranked source present (non-null).
# Explicit per-field ranking is authoritative and beats freshness.
for src in rule:
if src in candidates and candidates[src] is not None:
return candidates[src]
# Fallback: no ranked source present → freshest non-null (deterministic).
return _freshest_non_null(candidates, timestamps)
def resolve_house_field(
field: str,
candidates: dict[str, Any],
timestamps: dict[str, Any] | None = None,
) -> Any:
"""Pick canonical house field value per HOUSE_FIELD_PRIORITY.
``timestamps`` (source -> last_seen_at) makes first_non_null / fallback
resolution prefer the freshest source deterministically (#1539).
"""
return _resolve(HOUSE_FIELD_PRIORITY, field, candidates, timestamps)
def resolve_listing_field(
field: str,
candidates: dict[str, Any],
timestamps: dict[str, Any] | None = None,
) -> Any:
"""Pick canonical listing field value per LISTING_FIELD_PRIORITY.
``timestamps`` (source -> last_seen_at) makes first_non_null / fallback
resolution prefer the freshest source deterministically (#1539).
"""
return _resolve(LISTING_FIELD_PRIORITY, field, candidates, timestamps)
# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
# Legacy stub — kept for backward compat with existing __init__.py and tests
# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
def update_canonical_fields(
db: Any,
listing_id: int,
ext_source: str,
lot_data: object,
) -> None:
"""Legacy Stage 8 v1 stub — full arbitration deferred to Stage 8.x."""
pass