diff --git a/tradein-mvp/frontend/src/app/v2/page.tsx b/tradein-mvp/frontend/src/app/v2/page.tsx
index 7a2b16f7..3f6868ac 100644
--- a/tradein-mvp/frontend/src/app/v2/page.tsx
+++ b/tradein-mvp/frontend/src/app/v2/page.tsx
@@ -410,11 +410,22 @@ export default function TradeInV2Page() {
   // stale value is locked in forever (mirrors how `freshResult` already
   // overrides the same race for the post-submit path below). Cleared once
   // `restored.data` actually reflects this id (see effect below).
-  const [pendingRestoreId, setPendingRestoreId] = useState<string | null>(
-    null,
-  );
+  //
+  // Three states, not two: `undefined` means "no override, defer to
+  // readUrlId()"; `null` means "override to no-id" (handleNew's reset);
+  // a string means "override to this id" (a row was just clicked). Using
+  // plain `null` for both "no override" and "force no-id" was tried first and
+  // reintroduced this exact race for handleNew(): forcing pendingRestoreId
+  // from a bad id to `null` would, under `pendingRestoreId ?? readUrlId()`,
+  // fall through to readUrlId() on the very next render — which is still
+  // stale until router.replace("/v2") finishes — so the bad id came right
+  // back. The two intents need distinguishable values.
+  const [pendingRestoreId, setPendingRestoreId] = useState<
+    string | null | undefined
+  >(undefined);
 
-  const urlId = pendingRestoreId ?? readUrlId();
+  const urlId =
+    pendingRestoreId !== undefined ? pendingRestoreId : readUrlId();
 
   // Post-mount flag: readUrlId() is null on SSR but a UUID on the client's first
   // render, so any structure that depends on the id (e.g. the PDF <a> vs disabled
@@ -486,11 +497,12 @@ export default function TradeInV2Page() {
   // what the URL will become — rather than risk reverting to a stale read.
   useEffect(() => {
     if (
+      pendingRestoreId !== undefined &&
       pendingRestoreId !== null &&
       restored.data?.estimate_id === pendingRestoreId &&
       readUrlId() === pendingRestoreId
     ) {
-      setPendingRestoreId(null);
+      setPendingRestoreId(undefined);
     }
   }, [pendingRestoreId, restored.data]);
 
@@ -674,7 +686,8 @@ export default function TradeInV2Page() {
         setFreshResult(est);
         // A fresh submission always supersedes any pending restore-by-id
         // override (#2424 fix) — drop it so it can't shadow a later restore.
-        setPendingRestoreId(null);
+        // `undefined` (not `null`): there is no override to force, just none.
+        setPendingRestoreId(undefined);
         // A new estimate consumed quota and added a history row — refresh both
         // so the TopNav badge + «Предыдущие оценки» overlay reflect it.
         void queryClient.invalidateQueries({
@@ -695,6 +708,9 @@ export default function TradeInV2Page() {
 
   function handleNew() {
     setFreshResult(null);
+    // `null`, not `undefined`: forces urlId to no-id immediately, synchronously
+    // clearing restoreActive/restoreError even before router.replace below
+    // finishes and readUrlId() would otherwise still read the stale id.
     setPendingRestoreId(null);
     router.replace("/v2", { scroll: false });
   }